Last updated: November 11, 2026. We re-checked both brands on their US stores and help centers. The Tractive DOG 6 costs $79 (we had listed about $50), its cheapest US plan is $108 a year (we cited about $5 a month, and about $13 for a monthly plan the US store doesn’t sell), and its battery is rated at 14 days with Power Saving Zones and 6 without (we had only ā€œup to 2 weeksā€). Fi now charges $129 for the Series 3+ at checkout plus a plan billed at activation (we had said the collar shipped free with a $20 activation fee, which Fi’s checkout doesn’t show). We added Fi’s own battery figures by activity level, corrected the coverage claims, and replaced an unsourced lost-pet statistic.

Quick Answer: Buy the Tractive GPS DOG 6 if you want the cheapest live GPS tracking on a collar you already own: $79 plus a US plan from $108 a year or $144 for two years, so $223 for two years all in (Tractive’s US store, November 11, 2026). Buy the Fi Series 3+ if you’d rather charge rarely and your dog destroys clip-on tags: Fi rates it at up to 3 months per charge for a mostly-at-home dog, against up to 14 days for the DOG 6, but it costs $129 plus a plan from $99 for the first year, or $318 for two years. Tractive also works in far more countries.

Tractive and Fi are the two GPS dog trackers people cross-shop most. Tractive is a small clip-on tracker that goes on any collar or harness. Fi’s Series 3+ is a complete collar with the tracker built in. We compared the current Tractive GPS DOG 6 and Fi Series 3+ on price, battery, coverage and build, using each maker’s own US store, plans page and help center on November 11, 2026. We don’t test trackers ourselves: battery and coverage figures below are the makers’ claims.

Tractive vs Fi by the numbers

Tractive vs Fi at a glance

SpecTractive GPS DOG 6Fi Series 3+
DesignClip-on tracker, fits collars up to 2.8 cm wideBuilt-in collar (tracker plus Fi band)
Hardware price (Nov 11, 2026)$79 (DOG 6 XL $89)$129
Cheapest planBasic $108 a year, or $144 for 2 years$59 for the first 6 months, then $99 per 6 months
1-year planBasic $108, Premium $120$99 first year, renews at $189
2 years, all in$223 (Basic) or $247 (Premium)$318 (2-year plan)
Monthly plan in the USNot listedNo (6-month minimum)
Battery claimUp to 14 days with Power Saving Zones, 6 days withoutUp to 3 months (low activity), 4–6 weeks (moderate), up to 2 weeks (high)
Battery while searchingMuch shorter in LIVE modeAbout 2 days in Lost Mode
NetworkLTE (CatM1) or 2G via 500+ partners, incl. AT&T, Verizon, T-MobileAT&T LTE-M
Where it works175+ countries (Basic: one country of your choice)US, Canada and Mexico
Water rating"100% waterproof," per Tractive (no IP rating on the US product page)IP68 (1.5 m for 30 min) and IP66K

Tractive GPS DOG 6: Best Value and Best for Travel

Tractive GPS DOG 6

Best value Ā· $79 at tractive.com (US), Nov 11, 2026 Ā· plans from $108 a year
  • Clip-on tracker for dogs over 4 kg (about 9 lb). Tractive's rubber clip fits collars up to 2.8 cm (about 1.1 in) wide; the XL clip fits up to 4 cm.
  • Battery rated at up to 14 days with Power Saving Zones and up to 6 days without (930 mAh). The DOG 6 XL ($89, dogs over 20 kg) is rated at up to 42 and 20 days.
  • US plans: Basic $108 a year or $144 for 2 years; Premium $120 a year, $168 for 2 years or $300 for 5 years. Tractive Care (replacement if lost, damaged or stolen) costs $1 to $2 a month extra.
  • Premium adds family sharing, worldwide coverage, 365 days of location history (Basic keeps 24 hours) and GPS data export.

Tractive is the cheaper way into live GPS tracking. The tracker costs $79, $50 less than Fi’s collar, and a two-year Basic plan is $144, so two years cost $223 in total. Because it clips on, your dog keeps whatever collar or harness it already wears, and you can move the tracker between collars. That suits a dog that needs a martingale for walks or a breakaway collar at home.

Coverage is Tractive’s other big advantage. Tractive says its trackers work in more than 175 countries through over 500 network partners, including AT&T, Verizon and T-Mobile in the US. Read the plan small print, though: Tractive’s help center says that on the Basic plan ā€œyour tracker only works in one country of your choice,ā€ so pay for Premium if you take your dog abroad.

The trade-off is charging. Fourteen days is the best case and needs Power Saving Zones, Wi-Fi zones such as your home where the tracker stops using GPS. Without them, Tractive’s own battery table says up to 6 days, and continuous LIVE tracking during a search drains it faster still. Our Tractive review has the full plan table.

Fi Series 3+: Best Battery and Best for Escape Artists

Fi Series 3+ Smart Collar

Best battery Ā· $129 at fitracking.com, Nov 11, 2026 Ā· plan billed at activation, from $59 for the first 6 months
  • Tracker built into a Fi collar band, so there's no tag to chew off. Fi calls the Series 3+ "chew-proof, water-proof, and generally dog-proof."
  • Battery: up to 3 months at low activity, 4 to 6 weeks at moderate activity, up to 2 weeks for a dog outdoors most of the day, about 2 days in Lost Mode (Fi's battery guide).
  • Plans: 6 months $59, 1 year $99 or 2 years $189 for the first term, renewing at $99, $189 or $339. Fi says all plans have a minimum 6-month commitment.
  • AT&T LTE-M network; works in the US, Canada and Mexico. IP68 rated (1.5 m for up to 30 minutes) plus IP66K for high-pressure spray.

Fi is built for the dog that doesn’t stay put. Because the tracker is part of the collar, a dog can’t pull off or chew off a dangling tag, and the long battery means it’s more likely to be charged on the day your dog slips out. Fi alerts you when your dog leaves a Safe Zone and switches to Lost Mode for faster location updates. Lost Mode cuts the battery to about two days, per Fi.

Check how you’ll pay before you order. Fi’s FAQ says ā€œyou pay for the tracker at checkout, and your membership is charged when you activate,ā€ so the $129 collar is only the first bill. The first-term plan prices are introductory. A 1-year plan is $99 for the first year and renews at $189. That makes the second year of Fi cost more than two years of Tractive Basic. Fi’s shop also showed a 30%-off code on November 11, so check for a promotion before you pay full price.

Fi’s collar is also its limitation. You use Fi’s band or a Fi-compatible collar, and Fi’s $29 martingale band is listed only for the older Series 2. If your dog needs a martingale for walks, it wears that as a second collar (see our martingale collar guide).

Fi’s other trackers: Mini and Ultra

Fi now sells two clip-on trackers alongside the Series 3+, which closes some of the gap with Tractive:

Our Fi collar review covers the Fi lineup in more detail.

Which should you buy?

Whichever you buy, keep an ID tag with your phone number on the collar. A tracker with a flat battery or no signal can’t help, and a tag is how a stranger who finds your dog reaches you.

How these two fit the wider market

Tractive and Fi aren’t your only options. If monthly fees are a dealbreaker, read our guide to a GPS dog tracker with no subscription first, since both Tractive and Fi require a plan. The Whistle GO Explore, once the third big name, was discontinued in 2025 and no longer works (see our Whistle dog tracker page). On a tighter budget, our Weenect vs Tractive comparison pits two cheaper cellular trackers against each other, and if you’d rather contain your dog than track it, our Halo vs SpotOn comparison covers the two big GPS wireless fences. For the full field, start with our best GPS dog tracker roundup, or for cats the best GPS cat tracker.

The bottom line

The Tractive vs Fi choice comes down to cost and coverage against charging and build. The Tractive GPS DOG 6 costs $79 plus $108 a year or $144 for two years, works in more than 175 countries on Premium and clips onto any collar, but its battery is rated at 6 to 14 days. The Fi Series 3+ costs $129 plus a plan from $99 for the first year, works in the US, Canada and Mexico, and Fi rates its battery at up to 3 months for a mostly-at-home dog, with a collar a dog can’t chew a tag off. For most budget-minded owners, Tractive is the better buy. For an escape artist that stays in North America, Fi is worth the extra money.

Sources (checked November 11, 2026): Tractive US store and price API (DOG 6, DOG 6 XL), Tractive US plans page, Tractive battery table and help center (Basic plan coverage); Fi shop, Fi help center articles on battery life, network coverage, billing, water resistance and supported countries, and Fi’s product feed; Weiss, Slater and Lord, Animals (2012).